Wednesday, February 25, 2015

Welch, A. G., Napoleon, L., Hill, B., & Roumell, E. (2014). Virtual Teaching Dispositions Scale (VTDS): A Multi-dimensional Instrument to Assess Teaching Dispositions in Virtual Classrooms. Journal of Online Learning & Teaching, 10(3).

Category: Technology, Research Methods, Theory & Rhetoric, Communication Design

Summary:

The authors set out to create an instrument for measuring instructors to determine if they are predisposed on teaching online. Their resulting instrument contained four factors, and 25 criteria:

"Factor 1: Social Presence
  • Social I am empathetic to the needs of my students.  
  • I relate with students as people. 
  • I am tactful with students in emotionally stressful situations.
  • I am flexible in dealing with students' needs (due dates, absences,etc.).
  • I try to establish a welcoming learning environment. 
  • I understand the needs of my students.
"Factor 2: Virtual/TechnologicalPresence
  • I adapt well in online delivery formats.
  • I maintain genuine and meaningful contact in online formats.
  • I project interpersonal skills in the online environment.
  • I strive to continually improve performance in the online classroom.
  • I maintain a highly visible presence in online formats.
  • I am intrinsically motivated to master new information technology. 
  • I utilize new technologies to enhance learning. 
  • I communicate comfortably almost entirely through writing. 
"Factor 3: Pedagogical Presence
  • I respond to student inquiries in a timely manner. 
  • I return work to students promptly. 
  • I create a schedule and stick to it. Pedagogical I am organized. I communicate clearly and effectively in writing. 
"Factor 4: Expert/Cognitive Presence
  •  I demonstrate commitment to academic expertise. 
  • I have a passion for education.
    I make content meaningful for the learner. 
  • I anchor learning strategies in the context of my subject matter.
    I adapt learning strategies within the context of my subject matter. 
  • I am very knowledgeable in my content area" (Welch, Napoleon, Hill, & Roumell, 2014, p. 457).
This document could help instructors determine if they are well-suited for online education. 

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

Lloyd, S. A., Byrne, M. M., & McCoy, T. S. (2012). Faculty-perceived barriers of online education. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 8(1), 1-12.

Categories: Communication Design, Technology

Summary and Citations:

"This study sought to identify the most prevalent barriers to online instruction for the faculty" (Lloyd, Byrne, & McCoy, 2012, p. 1) at a southeastern university in the United States. The results came from a survey group of 75 faculty members. They found that those with experience in online education were less resistant to teaching online courses.

The insights from their literature review are particularly helpful for those researching this field:

"The fact that experience with and the degree of experience with online education breaks down barriers to education is not thoroughly addressed elsewhere in the literature (Lloyd, Byrne, & McCoy, 2012, p. 8).

"Of the eight conditions that facilitate faculty involvement in online education identified by Ely (1999), the three conditions that are perceived by faculty to have the greatest impact on the implementation of new online programs include adequate institutional resources, appropriate knowledge and skills, and a general dissatisfaction with the status quo  (Ensminger & Surry, 2002). Instructors' willingness to participate in distance education is positively impacted by increased training, an expectation of high student evaluation scores, and comfort with the technology, while negatively impacted by communication issues such as lack of visual cues and other forms of social contact (Lee & Busch, 2005). However, faculty-perceived barriers to teaching online also include: a lack of compensation for time  and class sizes; added responsibilities; inability to grasp visual cues from students; concerns about the quality of the content; concerns about the ownership of courses developed;  inadequate training and resources; increased workload; the value toward promotion and tenure; a lack of administrative and technical support; a lack of experience with online teaching; and a change in the faculty's institutional role (Bower, 2001; Haber & Mills, 2008; Johnson, 2008; Lyons, 2004; Panda & Mishra, 2007; Ryan, Hodson-Carlton, & Ali, 2004, 2005; Schifter, 2002; Seaman, 2009; Shea, 2007; Singh & Pan, 2004). Maguire (2005) identified additional barriers, which include: increased workload that deterred from research time; lack of recognition in both the area of tenure and promotion and equality in regards to  face-to-face instruction; and a lack of monetary compensation for developing or teaching online courses. Faculty were also concerned about lack of standards in online education, the  impact that the online atmosphere would have on job security, and the quality of  instruction" (Lloyd, Byrne, & McCoy, 2012, p. 2).

"In an attempt to reconcile the broad-based literature that identifies various individual barriers to online education, Muilenburg and Berge (2001, 2005) developed a comprehensive framework of barrier categories through factor analysis. They identified 10 constructs that incorporate barriers to online education and which form the basis for their framework.  While this framework proves useful in reducing and combining variables into meaningful constructs so as to test individual differences, it was written to be inclusive of the perspective of distance education institutions, users, developers, policymakers, trainers, and instructors, and has been used to this end (see Cho & Berge, 2002; Muilenberg & Berge, 2005). However, it is not clear whether perceived barriers to online teaching vary among faculty groups and what role previous experience with online education might have on faculty perceptions, which has obvious implications on training and implementation strategies at institutions of higher learning (Lloyd, Byrne, & McCoy, 2012, pp. 2-3).

This study directly reflects teacher perceptions, but the focus is primarily on getting instructors to overcome their hesitations about online learning.

Hartman, S. J., & DeMatteis, M. J. (2008). An Investigation of Faculty and Student Experiences and the Move to Online Learning Following Hurricane Katrina. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 4(1), 1-13.

Categories: Communication Design, Technology

Summary and Citations:

In addition to the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina, this natural disaster created an educational crisis for the University of New Orleans. This paper study presented online education as a method of dealing with institutional crisis. The University officials relocated to Baton Rouge following the disaster and decided to use online education as a means for meeting the school's needs in the wake of the disaster. This paper shared the ancidotal experiences of teachers and students from UNO's business school during an immediate, emergency shift to online education using the Blackboard learning management software.

Though offering online courses helped student continue their schooling, regain some normalcy in their life, and move past the disaster, the shift created stress for instructors and administrators. Those involved had never created an online course, and faced many of the difficulties those who embark in such an endeavor experience without training or knowledge of best practices. The commercial course management software facilitated this possibility, without it, they would not have been able to move forward with their courses. They were highly complimentary of the Blackboard LMS and the administration's choice to immediately shift to online education.



Monday, February 23, 2015

Hall Jr, O. P. (2013). Assessing faculty attitudes toward technological change in graduate management education. Journal of Online Learning & Teaching, 9(1), 39-51.

Categories: Communication Design, Technology

Summary and Citations:

 Hall's paper shared the results of a survey of 61 faculty member's perceptions about the learning technologies used in graduate management education. The study spent a significant amount of time promoting a "two-stage variable classification methodology based on neural nets and CART" (Hall, 2013, p. 48).

The results of the instructor perceptions survey boils down to recognizing that some faculty
adapted with the instructional shift, adopting the new technologies, and other resisted the change. The results supported theories and speculation about this in other literature.

Goldman, Z. (2012). Online MBA Asynchronous Discussion Workload and Value Perceptions for Instructors and Learners: Working Toward an Integrated Educational Model for Professional Adults. Journal of Online Teaching and Learning, 8(3), 174-188.

Categories: Communication Design, Technology

Subject and Citations:

How much value does an asynchronous discussion bring when considering time requirements? Goldman's study sought for perceptions of both teachers and students in his study of 72 instructors and 280 learners in an MBA program at Post University in Waterbury, Connecticut. "Descriptive statistics, analysis of variance (ANOVA), and covariance/correlation analysis were employed to explore the load and value perceptions of learners and instructors as well as to present the results" (Goldman, 2012, p. 175). The results were presented in well-designed correlation matrices, charts and graphs. 

The quantitative study's resulted by affirming two hypotheses, and rejecting one:
"1) Discussion did become the major engagement conduit for learners and instructors, consuming 55% and 65% of their total course hours, respectively. This was affirmed across all course levels throughout the program with the exception of the Capstone Writing course in which learners focused on developing and writing their projects.
"2) For both learners and instructors, discussion load perceptions were centered around "medium" (on a scale of "no load" to "very heavy" load) and value perceptions of learners and instructors were centered around "high" (on a scale of "no value" to "very high" value). This was affirmed for learners and instructors across all course levels throughout the program.
"3) The hypothesis that the value perception for discussion could be gauged and predicted by measuring the hours spent on discussion could not be affirmed and was rejected. No substantive associations were found for learners or instructors between hours spent and value perception for either course or discussion" (Goldman, 2012, p. 182).

The study seemed to support the idea that the value of the time necessary for asynchronous discussions was worth the engagement. The results focused on the perceptions about the time requirements and value, not the emotions and concerns of the faculty, which still appears to be a significant gap in the research.

Saturday, February 21, 2015

De Gagne, J. C., & Walters, K. J. (2010). The lived experience of online educators: Hermeneutic phenomenology. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 6(2), 357-366.

Categories: Communication Design, Technology

Summary and Citations:

De Gagne and Walters surveyed eleven online educators throughout the United States to learn more about their experiences with online education. They asked the following questions:

"RQ1. What concepts do online educators think are important in teaching online?
RQ2. What knowledge, skills, and attitudes do they perceive as essential in teaching online?
RQ3. What differences in terms of faculty role do they perceive between face-to-face instruction
and online teaching?
RQ4. What strategies do they use to facilitate active learning?
RQ5. What ethical and legal issues do they face in online teaching?
RQ6. What do they think academic leaders can do to help them achieve successful online
teaching?" (De Gagne & Walters, 2010, p. 358).

They then used rhetorical analysis, specifically the hermeneutic approach, to understand the instructor's perspective from the recorded interviews. By examining the the interviews, "five key themes emerged from11 respondents’ narrative accounts, including: (a) flexibility and convenience, (b) time- and labor-intensiveness, (c) communication skills, (d) learner-centeredness, and (e) continuing education and training. These identified themes were important in illustrating online educators’ experiences, which provided new perspectives and recommendations for the development and promotion of successful communities of online learning" (De Gagne & Walters, 2010, p. 357). Part of these insights included a perceived shift in power in the online teaching experience where instructors noticed the need for students to fulfill greater rolls and responsibilities.


This well-crafted study shared the perspectives of 12 online teachers, and helped us understand their beliefs about online education and best practices. It also revealed some opportunities for future research, specifically, "(1) This study suggests that faculty’s knowledge level about legal issues related to online teaching appears to be narrow or limited. Interviews with a larger population about specific legal-related questions should be conducted to fully explore the degree of the knowledge gap. (2) This study determined what knowledge, skills, and attitudes are considered important to online teaching, but it did not specifically address how important these aspects are for teachers who make the transition to online learning. 3. Similar research should be conducted with online students as the target population to determine if their perceptions are aligned with the areas identified in this study by the online educators" (De Gagne & Walters, 2010, p. 365).
 

Batts, D. (2008). Comparison of student and instructor perceptions of best practices in online technology courses. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 4(4), 477-489.

Categories: Technology, Communication Design

Summary and Citations:


Batts' study investigated student and instructor perceptions of Chickering & Gamson's (1987) principles of good practice in undergraduate education.

"The Seven Principles assert that good practice in undergraduate education (a) encourages student faculty contact, (b) encourages cooperation among students, (c) encourages active learning, (d) gives prompt feedback, (e) emphasizes time on task, (f) communicates high expectations, and (g) respects diverse talents and ways of learning (Chickering & Gamson, 1987)" (Batts, 2008, p. 477).

Batts modifed the Online Teaching Practices survey developed by Taylor (2002) and administered to six instructors and 93 students. Both students and instructors felt that two of the seven were successfully employed in the classroom, with the other five being partially employed.

Batts succeeded in measuring and reporting the results of this quantitative study, yet the scope of the study did aim to truly measure teacher perceptions about online teaching, it measured perceptions of how well best practices in online teaching were employed.